She Went to the Gym While She Hired a Hitman to Kill Her Husband
- Strange Case Files
- Feb 18
- 4 min read
The Dalia Dippolito Case
The Morning Everything Was Supposed to Happen
On the morning of August 5, 2009, Dalia Dippolito left her townhouse in Boynton Beach, Florida, and went to the gym.
According to investigators, she believed that while she was gone, a hired killer would be inside her home carrying out a plan to end her husband’s life.
What she did not know was that her husband was already safe and that police were waiting for her return.
Within hours, she would be under arrest, and the case would begin a legal journey that lasted nearly a decade.
A Marriage That Formed Quickly
Only months earlier, Dalia and Michael Dippolito had married and moved into the townhouse together. From the outside, their life appeared ordinary, but the relationship had moved fast and was already strained.
Michael had a complicated past. Years earlier, he had served time in federal prison for fraud-related offenses and was trying to rebuild his life. Not long after the wedding, he transferred ownership of the townhouse into Dalia’s name, something prosecutors later argued created a financial motive and helped explain the rapid deterioration of the relationship.
Trouble Before the Sting
The marriage had shown signs of serious conflict even before the murder-for-hire investigation began.
In 2008, Michael was arrested after cocaine was found in his car during a traffic stop. The charges were later dropped. During later court proceedings, prosecutors argued that the drugs had been planted and presented testimony supporting the theory that Dalia had been responsible. The defense disputed aspects of that narrative, but the incident was introduced at trial as background evidence showing the state of the relationship.
By 2009, the marriage was already unstable.
The Phone Call That Started the Investigation
Around this time, Dalia reconnected with a former boyfriend, Mohamed Shihadeh. Their conversations eventually raised concerns.
In July 2009, Shihadeh contacted the Boynton Beach Police Department and told investigators he believed Dalia was serious about wanting her husband killed. Police asked him to cooperate, and he agreed to act as a confidential informant.
From that point forward, conversations were recorded.
Meetings That Were Being Watched
Over the following days, investigators recorded conversations in which prosecutors later argued that Dalia discussed payment and timing for a killing.
Police arranged a meeting between Dalia and a man she believed was a hitman. The man was actually an undercover detective. Their meeting was recorded, and prosecutors later told jurors that she agreed to pay thousands of dollars and indicated she wanted the killing carried out soon.
Investigators then prepared a sting operation.
The Staged Crime Scene
On August 5, 2009, Michael was quietly removed from the townhouse and kept safe.
Inside the home, detectives staged a crime scene. When Dalia returned from the gym, officers told her there had been a shooting and that her husband was dead.
Her reaction was recorded on video.
Within minutes, she was arrested.
Footage from the operation was later released publicly and widely broadcast, making the case one of the most recognizable sting operations in the United States.
The Explanation That Became Central to the Case
After her arrest, Dalia offered an explanation that would become one of the most debated aspects of the case.
She testified that she believed the situation was staged. According to her testimony, she thought the meetings, the supposed hitman, and the staged crime scene were part of a reality-style television scenario or some kind of acting setup. She said she believed her husband was in on it and that she had been playing along rather than seriously planning a killing.
Prosecutors challenged that explanation, pointing to recorded conversations that occurred before any staged scene existed and arguing that the discussions showed genuine intent.
In the final trial, the jury rejected the defense argument.
Life While Waiting for Trial
The case did not move quickly. It stretched over years, with delays, appeals, and retrials.
During this period, Dalia became pregnant and gave birth to a son in 2011 while awaiting trial. Court testimony and local reporting later identified the father as a man named Robert Davis, who was described as being in a relationship with her during that time. He was not the informant who contacted police.
This detail added another unusual layer to a case that had already drawn national attention.
Three Trials Over Eight Years
The legal process was long and complex.
In 2011, Dalia Dippolito was convicted, but the verdict was overturned on appeal due to a jury selection error, requiring a retrial.
In 2016, a second trial ended in a mistrial when jurors were unable to reach a unanimous decision.
In 2017, a third trial ended with a guilty verdict for solicitation to commit first-degree murder.
Sentence and Appeals
In 2017, Dalia Dippolito was sentenced to 16 years in prison.
Appeals followed, focusing largely on investigative tactics and claims of entrapment, but the conviction was upheld, and higher courts declined to review the case further.
Nearly a decade after the investigation began, the legal process finally came to an end.
Case Facts
Location: Boynton Beach, Florida
Year: 2009 investigation, 2017 conviction
Victim: Michael Dippolito (intended target)
Responsible person: Dalia Dippolito
Outcome: Convicted of solicitation to commit first-degree murder and sentenced to 16 years; conviction upheld on appeal
Read Next:
Comments